 鲜花( 1181)  鸡蛋( 48)
|
本帖最后由 小黄 于 2009-12-21 13:39 编辑 3 g; [) K/ E8 b, L
你也别整呢些弯弯绕了。你就说吧:CIVIC和卡车撞,谁比谁更吸能?谁比谁更容易死?3 y; p' H8 |8 N
降龙十八掌 发表于 2009-12-21 11:33 
8 ?3 ^5 r9 t+ x4 R" m g. tThere is no data available. If you do have some, please share. But please don't make up scenarios and data yourself, that's 意淫. Use a published source, or statistically controlled experiment.
3 h8 p' {/ \* J1 e8 W( O5 P* q3 h# q
From the existing data, there are 3 types of death:7 c D8 q% T8 k4 w0 R$ u
1) MV: multi vehicle collision, like when a Civic hits another car/truck* n- ^2 \/ r) y6 `1 M
2) SV: single vehicle, like hitting a tree, or roll over
: H6 A9 J$ o" w* a% G6 r3) SV Roll: roll over, this a sub set of SV.4 L* C' O3 X( O; F$ f4 Y
* X* D, \& H" @/ T) A$ B1 q5 ^) lFor Honda Civic:
8 ~7 B9 H8 m7 F7 N$ V2 x. S! wMV 34
2 g( J. ^ A+ y0 x0 b' _0 TSV 33
- o. D3 Q3 V; P8 A" R, D/ CSV Roll 13
& ] a. O' y3 M J. S# l: E
+ K Y. H0 I, | z) ?. Z$ pFor Ford F150 (including super cab, crew cab):
; b3 x' [1 d I. BMV 28~34
- K% r2 [8 u' R. Z7 wSV 79~94
0 R! u' J6 a. ?2 G# \5 h: _# h8 XSV Roll 48~82. Q2 P8 m* L; A$ `- W2 j `: j
, n5 \5 x5 P; @9 u1 k! `0 u
For Chevy Silverado 1500:( _ ]2 z. ]+ v8 i
MV 403 } F( ] O0 i) l5 y9 p
SV 85
9 \9 ` u$ q. q4 B+ T4 WSV Roll 61 a5 E+ B$ y* x/ k& r$ K
# v _) x) G5 E: i' ^0 w& O7 H
As you can see, not only would the trucks roll over more easily, they don't perform better even in a vehicle on vehicle collision. So, yeah, Civic is definitely safer than F150 or Silverado. |
|