 鲜花( 1181)  鸡蛋( 48)
|
本帖最后由 小黄 于 2009-12-21 13:39 编辑
! T. W, {! K* Q你也别整呢些弯弯绕了。你就说吧:CIVIC和卡车撞,谁比谁更吸能?谁比谁更容易死?; r6 w% M, S' M4 B" Z
降龙十八掌 发表于 2009-12-21 11:33 
0 ~+ Z3 |, U! c, c; h; o, X; qThere is no data available. If you do have some, please share. But please don't make up scenarios and data yourself, that's 意淫. Use a published source, or statistically controlled experiment.* n% V: `* X7 f8 s7 M! @
% ~0 t8 o: ^1 G/ ZFrom the existing data, there are 3 types of death:
) W' v2 u& {0 l' h1) MV: multi vehicle collision, like when a Civic hits another car/truck; E5 z( d% Z9 f! x2 k$ b
2) SV: single vehicle, like hitting a tree, or roll over, G& m, m0 A( y7 H h. m# s
3) SV Roll: roll over, this a sub set of SV.& Q/ [. s, {; r& ~
n6 {8 {7 @' |. [* B: ?+ ~
For Honda Civic: h [2 H) p; y' v
MV 34
: s. [) y! e* ]- ^ USV 33, q7 k/ ~$ L- {: p* c
SV Roll 13+ _. A' A0 c4 D% n! ~
% W' b4 G" E3 Z8 l
For Ford F150 (including super cab, crew cab):/ S" l; J. s$ S& n5 \' q* V
MV 28~34! T' ^" N& j6 b$ y& @9 ^* O
SV 79~94
8 m9 K- {* I! q1 G% ]* bSV Roll 48~82
k/ q4 s1 U/ A: c9 @( I2 i$ I( B7 p+ }, X$ N% L
For Chevy Silverado 1500:
0 w* [7 H9 ~3 h& ~' G' `MV 406 l, s' b( x8 ^3 S7 E% V* A
SV 85
* j6 E- x7 K/ ^& ?% I mSV Roll 61
: c! c1 R! T& u' `+ |) Z( U ]9 \# }1 i
* U% }# q- M* aAs you can see, not only would the trucks roll over more easily, they don't perform better even in a vehicle on vehicle collision. So, yeah, Civic is definitely safer than F150 or Silverado. |
|