请教高人：CIBC Mortgage Cash Back Offer是不是很好？

caifan

刚刚打电话给CIBC问 cash back offer的详情，大致如下：
# i' a, A; Q3 g- y9 A0 f0 Y
1。三年固定利率3.3%, cash back 2%;
1 d$ B1 h* ~1 `2。五年固定利率3.99%, cash back 2%.
" I- Z/ d( F) s3。按照银行网站，五年固定利率5.39%, cash back 5%
1 q5 j: P  x( ~& r- z$ |1 u% Z& |
/ ?  K8 Z) U6 r% W# I另，做mortgage transfer, 而不是refinance, 银行可以支付lawyer's fee。
感觉选择3最值。各位高人有何高见？

caifan

7 @! L$ p% a3 B/ }+ w0 V1 N8 o+ t' {cibc的人好像是这么给我推算的：

2%现金返还三年期，相当于每年2/3=0.67%的折扣，3.3-0.67=实际利率2.63%
2%现金返还五年期，相当于每年2/5=0.4%的折扣，3.99-0.4=实际利率3.59%

! \6 |$ O: B! D  C2 I- N: Y- G按他的算法，5%现金返还五年期，相当于每年5/5=1%的折扣，5.39-1=实际利率4.39%，不是特别好。

我觉得他的算法不精确，好像是假定你会把cash back花掉。如果把cash back马上用于还贷，整个的贷款额就降低了，所以cash back越高越好。

Pierce.CIBC

Let's say a customer wants to transfer $400,000 mortgage to CIBC. He has 2 options.
3 B5 i3 k# S; T8 R+ z1.   3-year closed mortage with 3.3% and 3% cash back.
% R2 O& `/ k/ v: I) Q; ?2.   5-year closed mortgage with posted rate 5.39% and 5% cash back
# R  @' a. a+ h5 T' X  ?
Option 1. After 3% cash back, your mortgage amount will become $400,000*0.97=$388,000 with 3.3% interest
5 K# H  R' o5 N/ vIf you want to payoff your mortgage in 25 years. Monthly PMT $1896.44. The remaining balance is $356,393 after 3 years.

& H. ~! V5 O' ?5 Z# P% @Option 2. After  5% cash back, your mortgage amount will become
' P' }( y: g: o7 R* t( G$400,000*0.95=$380,000 with 5.39% interest.
0 G) ?& B4 y, o% VIf you want to payoff your mortagge in 25years. Monthly PMT 2295.21  The remaining balance will be $356,351.50 after 3 years
# V5 P" @6 k; Z, T; g' ^
Basically, for the above options, after 3 years, the mortgage remaining balance is similiar.
1 }& ~5 Y$ [( u/ l% ]+ X: H+ k) XIf you choose the 2% cash back with 3.3%, every month you save about $398.77 monthly payment for 3 years.  Total roughly saving ($398.77*12*3=$14,355)

诺言

能确认一下把mortgage从别的银行转到CIBC，CIBC负担全部律师的费用吗？

caifan

3# Pierce.CIBC
谢谢回复！我后来用网上的贷款计算器算了一下，五年选择5%的返还和5.39% 的posted rate确实不划算，主要因为5.39实在太高了。

caifan

用网上的贷款计算器计算，五年固定利率3.99%, cash back 2%比起现在单纯的五年固定利率3.59%要划算一些。

Rapala

问一个问题，如果是投资房，cashback算收入要交税吗？

caifan

银行网站说：
# r' t, r% p' E) `) N+ u- N, bThe Cash back amount is tax free as long as the funds are not used to earn income from a business or property.

Pierce.CIBC

4# 诺言
7 y' A0 y1 x5 G1 X1 q+ K7 z
There is no fee/cost to transfer your mortgage

tyyjohn

任何时间都可以转吗？  还是要等5年满了才能转？

诺言

4# 诺言
; J1 O2 b% h& D2 p4 D: t' P+ v
- i) h. M) w8 M+ {" a+ \There is no fee/cost to transfer your mortgage
Pierce.CIBC 发表于 2010-3-4 14:26

9 s0 w5 s' o- U- e9 t# r但是Title上面的mortgagee不是需要改吗？这个过程不需要律师吗？

Pierce.CIBC

CIBC got free AD from Globe&Mail

6 O) M- B. O: p0 b8 W% B- Yhttps://secure.globeadvisor.com/ ... /cnw/20100305/C7106

caifan

据我的重新计算，五年固定3.99% 加上2 % 现金返还大致相当于3.50%，这是相当不错的了。
3 `1 j7 m( p7 m" u/ n
居然有一位mortgage broker能给这个rate，但是prepayment是5%，不是我想要的 10%。

诺言

“In addition, there are no transfer-in fees for clients to move their mortgage to CIBC.”
3 x; T9 w" q6 t. L# ~. D. U这句话并没有解答new mortgage是否需要律师involve去land title office注册的问题啊？

caifan

“In addition, there are no transfer-in fees for clients to move their mortgage to CIBC.”
/ @" n3 D3 t1 a* y3 R9 k6 G" g这句话并没有解答new mortgage是否需要律师involve去land title office注册的问题啊？
诺言 发表于 2010-3-11 11:41

% q; y6 ^0 Y, o8 b8 S$ n这个我也问清楚了。我的mortgage broker读了fine print，说你想让银行代付律师和登记费，就得放弃现金返还，当然没有人会那样做。为此他可以另外给我一些现金返还，足够支付相关费用。他说这部分现金返还是他本人用自己积累的点数支付的，与cibc的offer无关。

诺言

这个我也问清楚了。我的mortgage broker读了fine print，说你想让银行代付律师和登记费，就得放弃现金返还，当然没有人会那样做。为此他可以另外给我一些现金返还，足够支付相关费用。他说这部分现金返还是他本人用 ...
caifan 发表于 2010-3-11 11:59

/ F& z- l2 V6 {  `' Q是实实在在的现金返还吗？我看一直没正面回答，感觉有点问题。

Pierce.CIBC

14# 诺言
) l& t  N; j' Q+ j3 ~

当您把mortgage转过来，cibc会给您mortgage注册，不需要花钱。

Pierce.CIBC

16# 诺言
: A# b' ]& c% w$ _$ Z# [! b
+ g0 ?2 a+ l9 E7 L) S3 p
是free money,直接打到您的银行帐号。